Boylan Soda, New York

Silky vanilla, dark cherry, and lively carbonation bring an old-fashioned soda-fountain character to Boylan Soda, New York. Available in Creme Soda and Black Cherry, these caffeine-free soft drinks are sweetened with pure cane sugar and presented in the embossed long-neck glass bottles closely associated with the Boylan name. Their full flavors and crisp effervescence continue a soda-making tradition that began with pharmacist William Boylan in 1891.

Product Details:

• Producer: Boylan Bottling Company
• Founder: William Boylan
• Ownership: Family-owned and operated
• Beverage Type: Carbonated soft drink
• Available Flavors: Creme Soda and Black Cherry
• Sweetening: Pure cane sugar
• Creme Soda Flavoring: Vanilla with hints of coffee and cocoa
• Black Cherry Flavoring: Cherry, wild cherry bark, and hints of bourbon and vanilla extracts
• Caffeine: Caffeine-free
• Alcohol: Non-alcoholic
• Packaging: Embossed long-neck glass bottle with twist-off cap

Sensory Description:

Creme Soda opens with fragrant vanilla and a soft confectionary sweetness, followed by subtle coffee, cocoa, and lightly caramelized tones. Its rounded flavor is lifted by firm carbonation, keeping the finish smooth but refreshed. Black Cherry is darker and more fruit-driven, combining ripe cherry sweetness with gentle tartness, wild cherry bark, vanilla, and a faintly spiced depth from bourbon extract. Both flavors balance generous sweetness with lively bubbles and a clean cane-sugar finish.

Awards & Accolades:

• Designation: Best of the Best Cream Soda, Sporked, 10/10, 2024

Producer’s Background:

Boylan Bottling traces its history to 1891, when pharmacist William Boylan developed a birch-derived elixir in his Paterson, New Jersey, apothecary and sold it from a barrel mounted on a wagon. He began bottling the beverage around 1900, establishing the foundation for a company that would expand from birch beer into a broad range of American sodas. Now headquartered in New York City, Boylan remains family-owned and is recognized for cane-sugar recipes, bold flavor profiles, and distinctive embossed glass packaging. Creme Soda and Black Cherry remain part of the producer’s core four-flavor collection.

Serving Suggestions:

• Serve: Chill thoroughly and enjoy directly from the bottle or poured into a tall glass over ice.
• Creme Soda: Pair with vanilla desserts, buttery pastries, salted popcorn, or a scoop of vanilla or coffee ice cream.
• Black Cherry: Pair with chocolate desserts, barbecue, burgers, aged cheddar, or cherry-based pastries.
• Floats: Add vanilla ice cream to either flavor for a classic soda-fountain float.
• Mixed Drinks: Use Creme Soda with aged rum or whiskey, or combine Black Cherry with bourbon, rye, or a non-alcoholic dark spirit.

Why Boylan Soda, New York:

Boylan Soda, New York offers two distinctive expressions of traditional American craft soda. Creme Soda delivers smooth vanilla richness with coffee and cocoa nuance, while Black Cherry provides deeper fruit, gentle tartness, and subtle botanical spice. Pure cane sugar, caffeine-free recipes, assertive carbonation, and vintage-style glass packaging make both flavors appealing for sipping, food pairing, floats, and creative mixed drinks.